PDA

View Full Version : Book review: Decision Points


Ragnar Danneskjold
11-12-2010, 08:10 PM
OK... So earlier this week when it was released, my copy of Decision Points, by President George W. Bush, showed up on my Kindle. I just finished it tonight.

Wow. What a nice inside-baseball story this is. Sure... it's no secret that I was (mostly) in line with Bush on his major decisions. A fan of his will probably have more fun reading this book than a detractor will. But I would issue a challenge to those that opposed Bush during his term: read this book. I think some of your preconceived ideas will be blown out of the water.

Some things didn't surprise me. Some things did. As fits his usual practice, he doesn't ever really get nasty... even in the places I wish he would. He stays classy, even when he's digging on somebody that deserves it. Some don't come out all so well. He nails some folk that really needed it: Jacques Chirac, especiallly. Some back home that needed naming-of-names get named.

The whole thing is a remarkably candid story about some very important times. I've always wondered, in those shots where you see a President of the U.S. and the President of Russia sitting together at the Olympics... and they're chatting back and forth... what are they saying? Two of the most powerful men on the planet making smalltalk. What sort of smalltalk is that, exactly? Well... we find out... and frankly I was put back in my chair with what Bush told Putin at the Olympics in China. Damn... say what you want but he's got cajones.

The people I would recommend this book for the most, are people that hate him. Most of them won't bother, of course, but they would benefit the most. Someting loud and clear that comes through is the thoughtfulness that went into every single decision. You may not agree with each decision, but you cannot say after reading this that he ignored other points of view. He understood them in spades.

I would highly recommend this book. It was a fun read that I couldn't put down.

WashingtonBay
11-12-2010, 09:03 PM
Good review :) I'll probably read it :)

cowgirlup@idaho
11-13-2010, 08:48 AM
Good review :) I'll probably read it :)

Me too. I've been watching his interviews on TV and am impressed. His presence and demeanor is thoughtful and respectful. He's well spoken, intuitive and sincere. When he is talking about his presidency and his book, it's not all about him.

Ragnar Danneskjold
11-13-2010, 09:56 AM
Something else: He's written it in a different format than I've seen before. Normally, you'd expect a more or less chronological story-- but that's not how this is. Instead... each chapter takes a topic, a major decision, and discusses that decision and it's background and implications all through the years. It bounces forward and backward in time, touching on all the various elements that led to-- and resulted from-- that "decision point". It's an interesting way to arrange it.

As such, and he talks about it in the epilogue, it doesn't even try to be an exhaustive compendium of everything that happened. He leaves many things out. Some topics didn't make the cut. The intent though, was to just highlight some of the larger, most far reaching things like 9/11, Iraq, Afghanistan, the banking crisis... and do those in depth.

cowboyup3371
11-13-2010, 10:23 AM
I thought about getting it. I also recommend people reading one about Ronald Reagan written by one of his Secret Service Agents. Very enlightening story both from his horse side as well as the political side.

outriding01
11-13-2010, 10:52 AM
Oh wow, sounds like a really great read! I cannot wait to get my hands on it!

cowboyup3371
11-13-2010, 10:37 PM
Picked it up tonight. Probably start reading it this week when I have time (work, school, kids, etc)

cowgirlup@idaho
11-14-2010, 05:40 PM
Went and got mine today!

cowboyup3371
11-15-2010, 10:11 AM
So I stayed home from work today after getting pretty sick last night and took the opportunity to do some reading of the book. I finished Chapter 1 and realized one reason why I think most people have a hard time with the way President Bush spoke and lived. In my eyes, it really boils down to the fact that he's a lot like the common person in the way he grew up and how he feels about things. Yes, he went to a boarding school in Andover MA because his dad did, Yale (because his dad did), and later Harvard (his own choice) Business School. However, he also spent a lot of time working on ranches and being a typical teenager/early twenties type of kid. He drank alot, acted stupid (drunk driving incident one year and being drunk and stupid at a Willie Nelson concert), and said things that most people wouldn't agree with.

But it's because he did alot of the same stuff a lot of us did when we were young that one, endears us to the person since they are like us and two, bothers most of us because deep down we think our politicians are the "cream of the crop" so to speak of our society. Look at the way people really treat Sarah Palin, a gal from backwoods Alaska who speaks of a common everyday lifestyle like living in the country. Too many of us nowadays I think are so scared of what our history really was that we don't think it is relevant in todays world. Yet, I also think that the honesty, hard work, and straight talk is what we need since that is what our country was truly built on.

Seriously, what is wrong with living in a 500 sq ft house (having just graduated from Harvard Business School) in order to take a job as a land man to research mineral rights? How is that any different from a person working in a factory or on an oil rig? How would we feel about our own kids who committed to work for a company for a specific amount of time but then blew it off? George's dad got pretty upset over that exact attitude once George tried to "quit a week early" from a drilling company in Lake Charles LA. I sure know that I stress to my kids that you say what you mean and mean what you say. Your word is your bond and if it can't be trusted than you are nothing to anybody.

Just my thoughts.

outriding01
11-15-2010, 03:04 PM
I'm excited, I just picked it up at the book store today. I've got a lot of studying to do, but as soon as I'm done with my test, I'm going to get started! The cashier at Barnes & Nobles probably thought I was crazy because I bought "Decision Points" and "Are You There Vodka? It's Me, Chelsea" by Chelsea Handler (from E!'s Chelsea Lately, hilarious!) Great combo, lol.